ARTICLE: Practicing Without Protection: Closing the POSH Gap for Women Advocates in India, AUTHOR: Tejeswini Ram SIngam
Women advocates in India spend their working lives securing justice for others, yet the law provides them with no dependable mechanism to secure it for themselves. The Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act 2013 (“POSH Act”) is premised on an employer-employee relationship, whereas the Advocates Act 1961 provides only a disciplinary remedy without comparable safeguards. This article examines that gap. It argues that a safe professional environment is integral to an advocate’s rights to dignity and to practise her profession. It also proposes a separate POSH-inspired redressal mechanism informed by professional-regulation models in the United Kingdom, the United States and Canada.
ARTICLE


Abstract
Women advocates in India spend their working lives securing justice for others, yet the law provides them with no dependable mechanism to secure it for themselves. The Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act 2013 (“POSH Act”) is premised on an employer-employee relationship, whereas the Advocates Act 1961 provides only a disciplinary remedy without comparable safeguards. This article examines that gap. It argues that a safe professional environment is integral to an advocate’s rights to dignity and to practise her profession. It also proposes a separate POSH-inspired redressal mechanism informed by professional-regulation models in the United Kingdom, the United States and Canada.
1. Introduction
Women are entering the legal profession in growing numbers. They advocate for the rights of clients, victims and others. They often do so within institutions where they continue to face structural vulnerabilities. Yet when harassment is directed against them, the profession does not provide a clear, uniform and complainant-centred redressal forum. This is the central contradiction confronting women advocates.
A woman advocate should be able to focus on her client’s case rather than her own safety. The POSH Act provides a structured redressal mechanism for women in workplaces governed by an employer-employee relationship. However, it does not extend to independent advocates. The Advocates Act, on the other hand, treats sexual harassment at best as “professional or other misconduct”. It does not prescribe the procedural safeguards necessary to make reporting meaningful.
2. Constitutional Foundation
The right to a safe professional environment is not a matter of courtesy. In Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, the Supreme Court held that sexual harassment violates a woman’s fundamental rights under Articles 14, 15 and 21. Consequently, it impairs her right under Article 19(1)(g) to practise any profession.
The preamble to the POSH Act reflects this constitutional principle. It recognises the right to life and dignity under Article 21 and the right to practise a profession. This includes the right to a safe environment free from sexual harassment. For an advocate, Article 19(1)(g) has direct practical significance. If she cannot enter a courtroom, bar room or chamber without fear, her ability to practise her profession is necessarily diminished.
3. Differences between POSH Act and the Advocates Act:
The POSH Act establishes a structured complaint mechanism for workplaces falling within its scope, whereas the Advocates Act primarily governs professional discipline. This distinction leaves women advocates without adequate protection.
Under the POSH Act, an Internal Committee must be headed by a senior woman employee. It must comprise at least 50% women members and include an external member. In contrast, Section 9 of the Advocates Act does not mandate the inclusion of a woman or an external member in a disciplinary committee. Consequently, a woman’s complaint may be heard by an entirely male committee.
The POSH Act also provides assistance in filing complaints and permits interim relief during an inquiry. Section 35 of the Advocates Act, however, merely provides for disciplinary proceedings against advocates for professional misconduct. It does not prescribe confidential complaint procedures or assistance for complainants.
The timelines further demonstrate the disparity. Under the POSH Act, an inquiry must be completed within 90 days, and the report must be submitted within 10 days. Conversely, Section 36B of the Advocates Act permits disciplinary proceedings to continue for up to one year before transfer to the Bar Council of India. This reflects the absence of a prompt complaint-focused process under the Advocates Act.
The POSH Act also provides for confidentiality and compensation for mental trauma and career loss. It further provides for awareness programmes and annual reporting. The Advocates Act contains no comparable framework. Its disciplinary remedies include reprimand, suspension or removal of an advocate. However, they do not directly address the protection or recovery of the complainant.
4. The Gap in Court
In July 2025, the Bombay High Court in UNS Women Legal Association (Regd.) v. Bar Council of India held that the POSH Act applies only where an employer-employee relationship exists. Since neither the Bar Council of India nor the Bar Council of Maharashtra and Goa employ advocates, the Act does not extend to women advocates. However, it continues to apply to the respective Bar Councils’ employees.
The Supreme Court Women Lawyers Association challenged the ruling by way of a special leave petition. A separate petition under Article 32 titled Seema Joshi v. Bar Council of India raises the same issue. Both matters have been connected before the Supreme Court.
On 18 September 2026, Justices B.V. Nagarathna and Augustine George Masih observed that the POSH Act could not be applied in a “straitjacket manner” to women in the legal profession. The Court directed the Union and the Bar Council of India to examine the Supreme Court’s 2013 regulations and jointly prepare a comparable framework for High Courts, district courts, tribunals and quasi-judicial forums. It also directed the BCI to ascertain whether State Bar Councils already have such regulations. The matter was listed for 25 November 2026.
The 2013 regulations approved in Binu Tamta v. High Court of Delhi established a Gender Sensitisation and Internal Complaints Committee mechanism for the Supreme Court’s precincts. They provide a precedent for a mechanism applicable to women advocates without requiring an employer-employee relationship. The Supreme Court has since considered these regulations as a possible model for a wider framework covering women advocates in other courts and tribunals.
The BCI has also issued POSH compliance guidelines for Bar Associations and legal institutions. These guidelines require awareness training and Internal Complaints Committees. They also provide for confidential complaints and protection against retaliation. Further, they contemplate interim relief, compensation, counselling and regular monitoring. However, they do not clarify whether the POSH Act applies to independent advocates.
5. What Women Advocates Report
Reports of harassment within the legal profession are fewer than expected. However, the available evidence indicates that this may be attributable more to silence than to safety.
A survey conducted by the Supreme Court Bar Association among 2,604 women legal professionals found that 16.1% had experienced sexual harassment. A further 12.7% chose not to respond. Among those who reported harassment or sought assistance, 57% faced professional backlash.
Similarly, a CLPR survey of 419 women working in the High Courts and Supreme Court found that 41% had experienced sexual harassment during their careers. Yet only 7% filed complaints. Further, 45.3% did not know where to report harassment, while 46% of those who took action faced retaliation.
These findings expose a troubling reality. Many women fear that speaking out may damage their professional reputation and deprive them of work opportunities. The vulnerability is particularly pronounced among junior advocates who often depend on senior colleagues for work guidance and professional growth. Consequently, many choose silence even after experiencing serious harassment.
6. Comparative Global Models
India need not develop an entirely new framework. Professional regulators in other common-law jurisdictions already recognise harassment by lawyers as a matter of professional discipline notwithstanding their status as independent practitioners.
In England and Wales, barristers are independent professionals. Yet the Bar Standards Board can investigate and discipline them for sexual misconduct. Its guidance connects such allegations with professional integrity, public trust in the profession and equality, diversity and inclusion. An independent review also recommended changes to reporting obligations to enable barristers to report harassment to the BSB or the Commissioner for Conduct.
In the United States the American Bar Association’s Model Rule 8.4(g) treats harassment and discrimination connected with the practice of law as professional misconduct. Its commentary defines sexual harassment to include unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favours and other unwelcome verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature.
Canada provides a particularly strong model for complainant support. The Law Society of Ontario prohibits lawyers from sexually harassing colleagues, staff, clients or any other person. It also provides a free Discrimination and Harassment Counsel service which offers confidential advice and explains available reporting options. British Columbia’s rules additionally prohibit reprisals against persons who raise harassment concerns.
These models demonstrate that professional regulation can address harassment without treating the regulator as the advocate’s employer.
7. Solutions:
7.1 A Profession-Specific Mechanism
The solution does not lie in mechanically extending the POSH Act to women advocates. The Bombay High Court has held that the Act requires an employer-employee relationship which does not exist between advocates and Bar Councils or Bar Associations. The Supreme Court has also recognised that the Act cannot be uniformly applied to women in the legal profession.
Instead, a separate redressal mechanism should be established through a woman-led committee comprising external experts. The mechanism should ensure confidentiality and provide assistance in filing complaints. It should also grant interim relief and prescribe time-bound inquiries while protecting complainants against retaliation.
The committee’s jurisdiction should extend to harassment in courtrooms, chambers, Bar Associations and other professional settings. It must account for the particular challenges of legal practice where professional seniority and dependence on professional networks frequently discourage women from reporting harassment.
7.2 Recommendations:
First, the BCI should expressly recognise sexual harassment and retaliation as “professional or other misconduct” under Section 35 of the Advocates Act. This would follow the approach adopted under the ABA’s Model Rule 8.4(g).
Second, every State Bar Council should establish an independent Sexual Harassment and Professional Conduct Committee. It should be headed by a woman chairperson and comprise at least 50% women members, together with an external member.
Third, every State Bar Council should appoint a confidential Discrimination and Harassment Counsel. The Counsel should guide complainants and explain the available reporting options before they decide whether to file a formal complaint.
Fourth, complaints against Bar Council office-bearers and senior advocates should be heard by an independent committee or a committee chaired by a retired woman judge. Complainants should also receive interim protection during inquiries.
Fifth, retaliation should be recognised as separate misconduct. Withholding briefs or professional opportunities and subjecting complainants to social boycott should attract disciplinary consequences. The SCBA survey finding that 57% of those who reported harassment or sought assistance faced professional backlash underscores the seriousness of this issue.
Finally, High Courts should introduce courtroom conduct protocols and designate officers to receive complaints. Regular inspections of court complexes should also be undertaken to ensure safety and access to basic facilities.
8. Counterarguments:
It may be argued that establishing a separate mechanism would dilute the POSH framework. However, the POSH Act can continue to serve as the constitutional and normative benchmark while a profession-specific mechanism addresses the limitations arising from its employer-based design.
Section 35 of the Advocates Act covers “professional or other misconduct” but does not define sexual harassment or provide for a woman-led forum and interim protection. Disciplinary powers by themselves cannot substitute an effective redressal mechanism.
Concerns regarding false complaints can be addressed through safeguards similar to those under the POSH Act. These safeguards permit action against malicious or knowingly false complaints while clarifying that the inability to substantiate a complaint does not automatically render it false.
To preserve judicial independence, complaints against judges should be routed through the administrative machinery of the concerned High Court. Complaints against advocates and Bar bodies can be addressed through a separate professional framework.
9. Conclusion:
A woman advocate who fears losing her briefs and depends on a senior advocate for her livelihood or is required to appear before the person she accuses is unlikely to approach a committee, however well designed. The law already recognises that a safe professional environment is integral to dignity and the right to practise a profession. India must now provide women advocates with a framework that gives effect to that recognition. It must draw upon the protective design of the POSH Act and incorporate professional-discipline models from the United Kingdom, the United States and Canada.
Footnotes
Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, (1997) 6 SCC 241.
https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1031794/The Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, preamble and ss. 2, 4, 9–17, 19 and 21.
https://doe.gov.in/files/inline-documents/DoE_Prevention_sexual_harassment.pdfThe Advocates Act, 1961, ss. 9, 35 and 36B.
Advocates Act, 1961, ss. 9, 35, 36B, in Taxmann’s Editorial Board, Advocates Act with Rules: Bare Act with Section Notes (2027 edn, Taxmann Publications, New Delhi, 2026).
UNS Women Legal Association (Regd.) v. Bar Council of India, PIL No. 16 of 2017 (Bombay High Court, 7 July 2025).
https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/uns-women-legal-association-vs-bar-council-of-india-609026.pdfSupreme Court Women Lawyers Association v. Bar Council of India, SLP (C) No. 34428/2025;
https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/supreme-court-hearing-posh-act-applicability-women-advocates-and-bar-council-of-india-310707Seema Joshi v. Bar Council of India, W.P. (C) No. 805/2025 (Supreme Court, 18 September 2026).
https://indiankanoon.org/doc/142555743/Binu Tamta v. High Court of Delhi, W.P. (C) No. 162 of 2013 (order dated 17 July 2013); https://clpr.org.in/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/27.-Binu_Tamta_and_Anr_vs_High_Court_of_Delhi_and_Ors_SCOR20230116748COM430774.pdf
Bar Council of India, POSH Compliance Guidelines, 3 March 2026.
https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2026/03/03/bci-posh-comliance-guidelines-legal-profession-icc-compliance-framework/Supreme Court Bar Association, Documenting Voices of Women Legal Professionals in India (2026).
https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/2026/03/23/scba-report-final-663271.pdfNiharika Mukherjee, “Sexual Harassment Faced by Women Lawyers in High Courts and Supreme Court: Initial Findings of Survey,” Centre for Law and Policy Research, 1 October 2026.
https://clpr.org.in/blog/blog-initial-findings-of-survey-sexual-harassment-faced-by-women-lawyers-in-high-courts-and-supreme-court/International Bar Association, Us Too? Bullying and Sexual Harassment in the Legal Profession (2019).
https://www.ibanet.org/bullying-and-sexual-harassmentBar Standards Board, Sexual Misconduct Guidance (2022).
https://www.sra.org.uk/solicitors/guidance/sexual-misconduct/Independent Review of Bullying, Harassment and Sexual Harassment at the Bar, Report (2019).
https://www.barcouncil.org.uk/static/8ae513e7-07e2-4b20-b49c1c8dbbfa1377/563cbd91-791f-4ce0-9aa12600331609c8/Report-master-file-6.pdfAmerican Bar Association, Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 8.4(g).
https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_8_4_misconduct/American Bar Association, Comment on Rule 8.4.
https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_8_4_misconduct/comment_on_rule_8_4/Law Society of Ontario, Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 6.3-3.
https://lso.ca/about-lso/legislation-and-rules/rules-of-professional-conduct/complete-rules-of-professional-conductLaw Society of Ontario, Discrimination and Harassment Counsel.
https://lso.ca/dhc/servicesLaw Society of Ontario, Report of the Activities of the Discrimination and Harassment Counsel (2020).
https://lawsocietyontario-dwd0dscmayfwh7bj.a01.azurefd.net/media/lso/media/dhc/documents/dhc-report-on-activities-july-to-december-2020-aodacl.pdfLaw Society of British Columbia, Code of Professional Conduct (2024).
https://www.lawsociety.bc.ca/getContentAsset/27b8a005-f43b-4209-93bd-ee9a8e96c65f/dfc3d011-8f63-43f6-9ed8-4b444333a1d0/BC-Code_2024-03.pdf?language=en-CA
